Everything about accounting for irrecoverable debts
The accounting of doubtful debts falls under account 654 of the chart of accounts, “Losses on irrecoverable debts”.

How to write off a debt and recover the VAT?
Accounting must give a true and fair view of the company’s actual situation. The description of transactions and situations must be adequate, honest, clear, accurate and complete. In accordance with the principle of prudence, there must therefore be no discrepancies between the reality of customer accounts and the accounting records.
As an expert and recognised debt collection agency, we come across far too many companies that do not respect this principle. Some are reassessed by the tax authorities during a tax audit because of non-compliant accounting entries. We therefore thought it useful to publish this article to recall the basic principles.
Our agency’s primary motivation is to recover your debts. But when that is not possible, we can also help you justify that they are irrecoverable, to protect you from a tax reassessment in the event of a tax audit.
This guide will help you better understand when a debt is doubtful or irrecoverable:
- What is a doubtful debt?
a. Definition
b. An example to help you understand
c. How to treat a doubtful debt?
d. Special case: taking out credit insurance - What is an irrecoverable debt?
a. Definition
b. An example to help you understand
c. How to account for an irrecoverable debt?
d. How to prove that a debt is irrecoverable? - How to recover the VAT?
a. VAT recovery: how to proceed
b. Special case: recovering VAT in the event of judicial liquidation
What is a doubtful debt?
Definition of a doubtful debt
A debt is considered disputed if the debtor:
- Is not in a position to honour it within the agreed time. In this case, we speak of a doubtful debt that is certain, liquidated and due.
- Disputes the debt in whole or in part. In this case, we speak of a doubtful debt that is certain and liquidated, but whose due status must be settled amicably or through the courts.
Warning: VAT recovery is not permitted for doubtful debts and may be reassessed by the tax authorities.
The mere fact that the debt is starting to age, and/or is disputed, or that there is no response to reminders, may allow you to treat it as disputed. Placing this debt with your debt collection partner, who will appear on the statement of debts, will also justify it.
An example to help you understand
Let us take an example to better understand how a customer and its disputed debt are characterised.
When its accounting year is closed, company A checks the balance of its customer accounts. It thus identifies that its customer B is at risk. Indeed, B is undergoing reorganisation proceedings and records a debt of €15,000 incl. VAT.
At this stage, it is therefore considered disputed.
How to account for a doubtful debt?
In this situation, the entries must be recorded in the accounts in 2 steps:
- Accounting step 1
1. Debit account 416 Doubtful or disputed customers
2. Credit account 411 Trade receivables - Accounting step 2
The creditor must also estimate the probability of non-payment and make provisions for its debts, following a rule for impairment. For example:
Debts under 3 months: 10% Debts between 3 and 6 months: 20% Debts between 6 and 12 months: 50% Debts over 12 months: 80%
This is what must be recorded in the accounts:
- Debit account 68174 Allocations to provisions for impairment of debts
- Credit account 491 Provisions for impairment of customer accounts
If it is an exceptional and unusual impairment (such that it was not encountered in previous years), account 6876 Allocations for exceptional impairment can then be used instead of account 68174 Allocations to provisions for impairment of debts.
WARNING: provisions must be made within the limit of the total amount excluding tax.
Only the yearly changes in impairment must be reported in the income statement. On no account should the provision already made be reversed in full and a new one set up.
To return to our example of customer B’s unpaid invoice of €15,000 incl. VAT, i.e. €12,500 excl. VAT, if an 80% provision has been decided, account 68174 must be debited by €10,000 and account 491 credited for impairment.
Special case: the creditor has taken out credit insurance
The creditor may then provision only the loss that will remain its responsibility after compensation by the credit insurance. It must deduct from the impairment the portion covered each year and adjust the amount of the provision. Let us analyse the probabilities and the entries that must be made.
The debtor pays when the creditor had made a provision? A reversal of the provision is required.
- Debit account 491 Provisions for impairment of customer accounts
- Credit account 78174 Reversals of provisions for impairment of debts
The risk of non-payment increases while the creditor had only partially provisioned: an additional provision must be made.
What is an irrecoverable debt?
Definition of an irrecoverable debt
A debt is irrecoverable when all chances of recovery disappear. This is evidenced by a certificate of irrecoverability, a judicial liquidation or a court decision dismissing the creditor’s claim.
Our agency can also certify that an unpaid invoice is irrecoverable for many different reasons: small amount, debtor gone without leaving an address, etc.
Warning: recovering VAT without justification may also be reassessed by the tax authorities, even where the debt is irrecoverable.
Let us return to our example of the customer under reorganisation proceedings to better understand. The liquidation procedure against customer B has been completed.
In this very specific situation, the assets did not make it possible to satisfy all the creditors. Company A is therefore considered to record a definitive loss of €15,000 incl. VAT.
As it is final, it is certified at this stage that it is therefore irrevocable.
How to account for an irrecoverable debt?
Here are the accounting entries to be recorded in the event of irrecoverability:
Debit the accounts:
654 Losses on irrecoverable debts
4457 VAT collected
Credit account 416 Doubtful or disputed customers.
Warning: to be able to write off the debt and recover the VAT, the irrecoverable nature of the debt must be proven. This is necessary but not sufficient. A very specific formality, described below, must also be complied with.
If you would like to know more about accounting for irrecoverable invoices, Cabinet Phenix, an expert in debt collection management, is at your disposal.
How to prove that a debt is irrecoverable?
To certify that its debts are irrecoverable, the company must request a certificate of irrecoverability, for example from the company in charge of its debt collection.
The certificate of irrecoverability is an essential document for obtaining a refund of VAT already paid to the tax authorities. Indeed, by making it possible to prove that an invoice is irrecoverable, the debt can be reclassified as a definitive loss. Without this document, it is quite simply not possible. But how do you obtain this certificate of irrecoverability? As a debt collection agency, we can provide it to you, but you can also call on a judicial liquidator or a judicial officer.
Please note, a request can only be made in certain situations:
- Company in judicial liquidation;
- Insolvent or deceased debtor (estate empty or unidentified), gone without leaving an address, or subject to personal reorganisation proceedings;
- Payment of the invoice by cheque with insufficient funds or stolen.
How to recover the VAT?
VAT recovery: how to proceed
If the creditor company pays VAT on receipt of payment, it must still justify the steps it has taken to recover its debt, including the VAT, even if it has not succeeded. Otherwise, the tax authorities may consider that the creditor showed laxity and may still reassess it and demand payment of the uncollected VAT.
If the creditor company pays VAT on the actual basis, in the month of invoicing, there is also the financial stake, because it can recover the VAT paid provided that it complies with the following formality.
Whatever the VAT regime, in the case of a fully or partially unpaid invoice, in order to recover the VAT paid, the creditor company must send its debtor a duplicate of the original invoice bearing the following statement:
Invoice remained unpaid for the sum of …€ (net price in euros) and for the sum of … € (corresponding VAT) which cannot be deducted (article 272 of the French General Tax Code, CGI)
Indeed, if the debtor company has not paid the VAT, it cannot deduct it; that is only fair. The creditor therefore has a duty to remind it, in order to shift the responsibility onto it. Naturally, it keeps a copy to justify its steps in the event of an audit. The creditor company can finally recover the VAT on the invoice that was not paid. From then on, if the debtor deducts the VAT, it is the debtor who will be reassessed.
Special case: recovering VAT in the event of judicial liquidation
VAT can be recovered from the date of the court decision pronouncing the liquidation. If the debt had been the subject of an impairment, it must then be reversed.
Here are the accounting entries to be recorded:
- Debit of account 491 Provisions for impairment of customer accounts
- Credit of account 78174 Reversals of provisions for impairment of debts
When closing your last accounting year, you identified several doubtful debts. To obtain payment of your unpaid invoices, calling on a debt collection expert is essential. However, our role does not stop there. Our consultants are also available to help you with accounting for debts and to justify that your debts are irrecoverable.
Being supported by a debt collection expert is essential for companies that face debts owed by their customers, want to obtain payment and wish to find a solution for optimal management of all their invoices, including when they are irrecoverable.
Cabinet Phénix helps you manage your irrecoverable debts better
Accounting for an irrecoverable debt follows precise rules, but beyond the accounting treatment, the challenge remains to limit the financial impact of unpaid invoices on the company’s cash flow. To secure your steps, optimise the monitoring of files and act at the right time, it can be useful to rely on a debt collection professional. Cabinet Phénix supports companies in managing their unpaid debts, in identifying suitable solutions and in putting effective actions in place to protect their trade receivables. Whether you are looking for a debt collection agency in Strasbourg, Paris, Lyon or Marseille, our team helps you secure your collections and durably reduce the impact of unrecovered debts on your business.

Save time and delegate the collection of your debts!
01 53 20 12 761 rue de Stockholm, 75008 Paris · contact@cabinetphenix.fr
Entrust us with a file



