Skip to content
Alert: we are currently the victim of an attempted scam. We never contact you from a number starting with 09 85 40… Alert: attempted scam under way
01 53 20 12 76 FR Simulator

The manager’s liability in the event of irrecoverable debts

Yes, the director’s liability can indeed be engaged, notably if faults have led to the debt becoming irrecoverable. In that case, the debtor cannot be held to be solely responsible.

Accounting and Finance Published on 9 January 2026 Updated on 22 March 2026 2 min read

Mismanagement

In France, company directors are subject to a duty of care. This means they are required to take all necessary measures to avoid foreseeable harm to third parties. Negligence in fulfilling this duty can result in their liability.

Certain management faults can notably contribute to irrecoverable debts:

  • Lax monitoring of customer payments, allowing delays to persist;
  • Partnering with insolvent customers or customers in a fragile financial situation;
  • Failure to commit to suitable debt collection procedures.

Legal breaches

The director’s liability may also be called into question in the event of breaches of legal obligations. Among the offences that may give rise to this liability are, notably:

  • Failure to declare irrecoverable debts in the balance sheet, which distorts the company’s accounts;
  • Breach of tax rules relating to the management of debts, such as failure to declare or pay the taxes due on those debts;
  • Failure to inform creditors and shareholders, which undermines the transparency of the company’s financial operations.

The penalties provided for these legal breaches may be civil or criminal, depending on their nature and seriousness.

The case of collective insolvency proceedings

Finally, in the context of collective insolvency proceedings (liquidation or judicial reorganisation), the director’s actions are examined in order to identify any irregularities that contributed to the deterioration of the company’s financial situation. For example, in the case of a claim to make up the company’s liabilities, if the director was negligent, they may be held liable and face legal proceedings.

What are the consequences for the director in the event of irrecoverable debts?

In the event of irrecoverable debts, the director may face 3 types of consequence:

  • If their civil liability is engaged, owing to a proven management fault, the director may be required to repay the irrecoverable debts from their personal assets.
  • If their criminal liability is engaged, owing to fraud or embezzlement, the director faces penalties such as fines or even a prison sentence in the most serious cases.
  • Finally, the director may also face professional sanctions, for example a ban on managing a company for a set period. This measure is generally imposed in the event of insolvency where a management fault has been proven.

Company directors can therefore be held liable for irrecoverable debts, notably when they result from a strategic error, a breach of legal obligations or negligent management. The serious consequences, both civil and criminal, should encourage directors to adopt proactive management of their debts and to turn to debt collection agencies to recover the sums owed to them as quickly as possible.

To avoid finding yourself facing irrecoverable debts that could engage your liability, get support from Cabinet Phenix: we will help you manage your company’s complex debt collection procedures.

Contact

Cabinet PhénixDebt collection agency in Paris since 2010
Working meeting in a conference room, backlit

Save time and delegate the collection of your debts!

01 53 20 12 76

1 rue de Stockholm, 75008 Paris · contact@cabinetphenix.fr

Entrust us with a file