Skip to content
Alert: we are currently the victim of an attempted scam. We never contact you from a number starting with 09 85 40… Alert: attempted scam under way
01 53 20 12 76 FR Simulator

How do you calculate the cost of debt collection?

The cost of debt collection is made up, on the one hand, of the provider's commissions and, on the other, of the sums not collected by that same provider, which must absolutely be included in the calculation. Otherwise any comparison would be incomplete.

Accounting and Finance Published on 6 August 2013 Updated on 22 March 2026 3 min read

A creditor with few files will also take little time to make a choice based on the commission scale of debt collection providers. If one provider offers a commission rate of 7% and another 14%, there is a strong chance that the creditor will settle on the cheaper of the two.

Yet the actions a provider takes will be correlated with its own hopes of gain. The higher a provider’s hopes of gain, the more actions it can take to recover the debt entrusted to it. This point deserves to be stressed.

WHAT DOES THIS IMPLY?

In case of failure: If the debt could not be recovered by the 14% provider, it could not have been recovered by the 7% provider in any case. Whereas the opposite is not necessarily true. In case of failure it makes little difference to the creditor, given that the bulk of a debt collection provider’s remuneration depends on success. So taking the risk of working with a better quality provider does not mean paying more.

In case of success: We can reasonably hope that on certain files the 14% provider, having taken more relevant and more numerous actions, will have obtained better results than its counterpart at 7%. It is difficult to project from a single file, even if the creditor has only one. We will give our example on 5 files of €5,000:

THE OUTCOME WITH THE AGENCY AT 7%

DebtorsPrincipal amountRecoveredCommissionsMoney returnedCost to the creditor
15 000,00 €€€€5 000,00 €
25 000,00 €€€€5 000,00 €
35 000,00 €5 000,00 €350,00 €4650,00 €350,00 €
45 000,00 €5 000,00 €350,00 €4650,00 €350,00 €
55 000,00 €5 000,00 €350,00 €4650,00 €350,00 €
TOTALS25 000,00 €15 000,00 €1 050,00 €13 950,00 €11 050,00 €

VERDICT: It is true that the agency at 7% receives 7% commission on the sums recovered. €15,000 x 7% = €1,050.

It is also true that out of €25,000 the sum returned is €13,950. The real cost to the creditor is therefore €25,000 - €13,950 = €11,050.

We consider that the sums not recovered are an integral part of the cost.

As a percentage this corresponds to 11,050/25,000 = 44.20%, so we have proof that the commission percentage alone (here 7%) means nothing.

THE OUTCOME WITH THE AGENCY AT 14%

DebtorsPrincipal amountRecoveredCommissionsMoney returnedCost to the creditor
15 000,00 €€€€5 000,00 €
25 000,00 €5 000,00 €700,00 €4300,00 €700,00 €
35 000,00 €5 450,00 €*763,00 €4687,00 €**313,00 €**
45 000,00 €5 200,00 €*728,00 €4472,00 €**528,00 €**
55 000,00 €5 000,00 €700,00 €4300,00 €700,00 €
TOTALS25 000,00 €20 650,00 €2891,00 €17759,00 €7241,00 €

* Files settled with penalties.

** The final cost of these files is lower thanks to the penalties that were recovered.

VERDICT: In the same circumstances, on the same files, the agency at 14% managed to recover one more file and fought to settle two other files with the penalties. Why? Its hopes of gain are higher, it takes more actions and they are targeted actions.

The real cost to the creditor is therefore €25,000 - €17,759 = €7,241.

As a percentage this corresponds to 7,241/25,000 = 28.96%

Paradoxically, with the more expensive agency, the creditor saves €11,050 - €7,241 = €3,809, i.e. 34.47% of €11,050.

IN CONCLUSION: Debt collection providers’ commissions are far from representing the whole of the costs. The unrecovered portion of the debts must be included in the costs. As in our example, for the 7% provider the unrecovered portion is sometimes almost as large as the provider’s commissions. Out of 5 files entrusted, the agency at 14% recovered only one more file than its counterpart and turned the whole situation around. Imagine what would happen with a much larger number of files?

To answer the question asked at the beginning of this article, “How to calculate the cost of debt collection?”, here are the formulas we propose:

THE COST OF DEBT COLLECTION = THE SHARE OF DEBTS NOT RECOVERED + THE PROVIDER’S REMUNERATION, PENALTIES RECOVERED

AS A PERCENTAGE = THE COST OF DEBT COLLECTION/TOTAL ENTRUSTED

This is how we analyse the results of the tests and compare our results with those of our peers.

Contact

Cabinet PhénixDebt collection agency in Paris since 2010
Working meeting in a conference room, backlit

Save time and delegate the collection of your debts!

01 53 20 12 76

1 rue de Stockholm, 75008 Paris · contact@cabinetphenix.fr

Entrust us with a file